Jamieson Roofing Inc.

A Guide to Siding Repair vs Replacement for Calgary Homes

Unsure about which side you should be leaning toward in terms of siding repair and siding replacement?

Each option comes with its unique set of benefits and considerations—and this ultimate guide will help you pick the right side like a total pro! 

While repairs are quicker and a more budget-friendly choice, matching your home’s existing siding style might be a challenge. Plus, it’s not always a long-term solution that works for all cases. On the other hand, siding replacement will be in it for the long haul and give you the chance to revamp your home’s style—but it does come with a heftier price tag.

Count on the Jamieson Roofing—a leader in roofing and siding in Calgary—to help you pick the better side of the coin for your home. Let’s get started! 

Table of Contents | The Ultimate Guide: Siding Repair Versus Replacement for Calgary Homes

1. What is Siding?

  • The Benefits of Siding Installation
  • The Types of Siding Material

2. What is Siding Repair?

  • Benefits of Siding Repair
  • Considerations for Siding Repair in Calgary
  • Costs of Siding Repair in Calgary

3. What is Siding Replacement?

  • Benefits of Siding Replacement
  • Considerations for Siding Replacement in Calgary
  • Costs of Siding Replacement in Calgary

4. Siding Repair vs. Siding Replacement

5. Superior Roofing and Siding in Calgary

What is Siding?

Before diving into the depths of siding repair vs siding replacement, let’s have a refresher on what it is exactly and how it transforms your home into a more comfortable and charming space.

The Benefits of Siding Installation

Siding is a protective material attached to the exterior side of a wall of a house or other types of buildings. Its main function is to shield the structure from the effects of weather, helping to maintain a stable interior environment while also elevating the property’s aesthetic appeal.

The Types of Siding Material

Siding materials can vary significantly and include options such as vinyl, wood, aluminum, fibre cement, stucco, and brick, among others. Each type offers different benefits in terms of cost, durability, maintenance, and insulation properties.

Because it’s an ultra-functional addition to your home that adds significant points in the visuals department, you want to ensure it’s always in tip-top shape.

What is Siding Repair?

Benefits of Siding Repair

One of the main reasons homeowners opt for siding repair is because it’s a quick fix that your wallet won’t have to shed too many pounds for. Patching up minor damages and painting over the work to match your current siding, can save you money compared to a full replacement. Siding repair also entails less time and labour, so you’ll be able to give your home a glow-up without the process interrupting your daily routine too much.

Considerations for Siding Repair in Calgary

1. Weather Conditions

While sidings are designed to weather through it all, it’s best to schedule the project during a time of year when the conditions are mild and dry outside. Extreme temperatures or inclement weather can make the installation process more difficult and potentially lead to delays.

A contractor who specializes in siding repair in Calgary can provide expert advice on the optimal time frame specific to the climate and your location in the city to ensure a smooth and successful project.

2. The Current State of Your Home’s Siding

Ultimately, siding repair isn’t always a suitable solution. While patching up minor damages can buy you some time, it may not be enough to prevent future issues from arising. In some cases, the siding damage might be so extensive that a replacement is the better solution to ensure the structural integrity & aesthetic appeal of your home’s exterior.

Additionally, there may be limited options for repairs depending on the style of siding on your home. 

The solution here is to speak with Jamieson Roofing—one of the leading siding companies in Calgary. Our team will be able to evaluate the current condition of your home’s siding and provide expert advice on the best options.

Costs of Siding Repair in Calgary

The average cost of siding repair ranges from $500 to $3000 or more. The total price would depend on the following factors:

  • the extent of the damage;
  • the type of siding material;
  • labour costs; and
  • the need for additional repairs (such as water damage underneath the siding). 

What is Siding Replacement?

The Benefits of Siding Replacement

As technology continues to evolve, count on it that siding won’t be left behind in the evolution. Newer siding options tend to have better insulation and weatherproofing. The result?

  • improved energy efficiency;
  • reduced energy bills;
  • improved comfort levels for the whole family (That’s right — summers and warmer winters!);
  • increased home value;
  • elevated curb appeal;
  • the option to choose from a wide range of colours, styles, and materials like wood siding to create your desired aesthetic; and 
  • the opportunity to customize your home even further, such as adding a stone veneer accent around your entryway or utilizing different styles throughout various parts of your home. 

Considerations for Siding Replacement in Calgary

1. Weather

Just like with repairs, siding replacements are also best carried out when the weather is mild and dry. As these projects take longer to complete, it’s essential to pick a time when there likely won’t be extreme temperatures or inclement weather that can impact the project.

2. Budget

While siding replacement can provide long-term savings on energy costs and potentially increase the overall value of your home, the significant investment upfront can be daunting for some homeowners.

Deciding on what your budget is and then consulting with reliable siding companies in Calgary will help you figure out your options.

3. Convenience and Comfortability

“Beauty is pain,” they said. And while there’s no actual “pain” involved in siding replacement (thank goodness), your convenience and comfortability are likely to be affected during the process.

Expect siding replacement projects to bring about noise and dust. If this bothers you & your family, you might need to temporarily relocate during the installation, and then you’ll have to take the time to drop in once in a while to keep an eye on the progress. Depending on the size of your home and the extent of work needed, this process could take several weeks or even months to complete. But, of course, you’ll come back home to a space that’s awe-strikingly beautiful. That’s a pretty small trade, right?

Costs of Siding Replacement in Calgary

The average price for siding replacement in Calgary ranges from $5 to $20 per square foot. Ultimately, the final price depends on factors such as the size of the home, the siding material of choice, the complexity of the installation (including removing the old siding and preparing the walls), and the overall labour costs.

Here’s a general breakdown of the costs of siding replacement in Calgary based on material:

1. Vinyl Siding: This is often the most cost-effective option and can range from around $5 to $10 (CAD) per square foot installed.

2. Wood Siding: Wood can vary significantly based on the type of wood and the style of siding, with costs typically ranging from $6 to $12 (CAD) per square foot.

3. Aluminum Siding: Prices for aluminum are comparable to those of vinyl, but can be slightly higher, ranging from $6 to $12 (CAD) per square foot.

4. Fiber Cement Siding (e.g., Hardie Board): This is a more premium material that can range from $7 to $14 (CAD) per square foot installed.

5. Stucco: The cost for traditional stucco siding can vary widely, but expect to pay around $7 to $20 (CAD) per square foot.

Siding Repair vs. Siding Replacement

Now, let’s get to the bottom line: should you be opting for siding replacement or siding repair in Calgary?

Begin with carefully assessing the age and condition of the current siding. If the material is relatively new and in good shape, opting for repairs can be a practical choice. Small issues such as cracks, holes, or minor damage can often be fixed without having to replace the entire siding. However, if your siding is showing signs of wear and tear due to age or has significant damage that cannot be easily repaired, it may be more cost-effective in the long run to go for a complete replacement. Ignoring these issues can lead to further problems down the line, such as water damage or even mould growth.

In addition to evaluating the state of your siding, it’s important to consider the costs and timelines involved. Repairing your siding is typically faster and more affordable than replacing it, but if the damage is extensive and widespread, a full replacement may be necessary to prevent more severe and costly issues in the future.

As one of the leading siding companies in Calgary, what’s our take on this showdown?

The Verdict

Siding replacement is often the winning choice. Replacing your siding can be a substantial investment both financially and time-wise as it may ultimately provide better long-term protection for your home. Having to disrupt your schedule often to be on the lookout and watch over repair projects could end up being more time-consuming in the long run.

Say goodbye to these disruptions with siding replacement. You’ll be on your way to experiencing better comfort when the weather gets too extreme, lower energy bills, and increased home value. And let’s admit it—it’s an excuse to revamp the look of your home too!

A completed siding replacement project by Jamieson Roofing

Superior Roofing and Siding in Calgary

For roofing and siding in Calgary that withstand it all—call the Jamieson team.

We’ll be right by your side to transform your house into a stellar and comfortable space to call home.

By consistently delivering high-quality workmanship, competitive prices, and unparalleled customer service, that’s how we’ve become one of the leading siding companies in Calgary.

Talk to us today to get started with superior siding replacement!